The Silent Grief of Falling: Navigating the Loss of Independence in Later Life

The Silent Grief of Falling: Navigating the Loss of Independence in Later Life

“I don’t want to lose my independence” is a sentence I hear from almost every person I have seen who has fallen. It doesn’t matter if they have incurred a physical injury or not.  That’s not where the fear is coming from. The fear is about the consequences of the fall: the fear of becoming dependent on others, of possibly having to rely on others for more care, and the fear they may not be able to stay in their own home if further falls occur.

The Independence Continuum

As we go through life our level of independence changes. It is dependent on age, mental capacity, financial status, physical ability, and lived experience.  As babies, we are unable to survive without the intervention of our parents. Gradually, as one grows from a young child to a teenager to a young adult, we become less dependent on others. Our physical ability to look after ourselves and our mental ability to make decisions for ourselves allow us to have a level of independence that, for the most part, we maintain throughout our middle age and often well into our 70s. But as we grow older, we are often faced with health challenges that start to challenge our physical independence in particular.

The 5 Stages of Fall Grief

When we think of grief, we usually associate it with the loss of a loved one, but grief takes many forms. For older adults, one of the most silent yet profound forms of grief can come after a fall — a moment that may mark the beginning of a new, more dependent phase of life. Grief is a transformational experience and can best be seen through the eyes of Elisabeth Kubler-Ross, who identified  in her 1969 book, On Death and Dying,¹ the 5 stages of grief — the journey most people experience when suffering  a loss; in this case the potential loss of independence after a fall.

Stage 1: Denial

Often the first reaction many older adults have after a fall starts with a pre-fall assumption that “It won’t happen to me,” and progresses to “It wasn’t too bad.” Their aim is to downplay the event, insisting that they are fine, refusing to go to the hospital, and/or rejecting offers of help. This isn’t stubbornness — it’s a way to preserve the sense of control they are afraid of losing.  The faller dismisses the potential risks, believing falls are a problem for others, not for them.  This denial provides a temporary reprieve from having to face the implications of what has just happened to them.

This denial can also be seen in the form of reluctance to implement safety measures to reduce the risk of future fall events, such as avoiding the use of a walker or cane, not installing grab rails in the shower, or refusing to wear non-slips socks in the shower. The denial allows the faller, in their own mind, to maintain their independence. However the denial can be shattered when another fall occurs.

Stage 2: Anger

As reality begins to sink in — perhaps during a hospital stay or during a painful rehabilitation process — anger often emerges. The faller may ask, “Why me?” as they experience a sense of injustice that it is happening to them and their life is not the same. The fall may force them to confront their mortality and limitations caused by the ageing process, such as weakened muscles, reduced balance, or slower reaction times — all of which can cause further falls.

This anger is often caused by a threat to the faller’s independence, the fear of being seen as a burden by family and friends, and the loss of a life once lived freely. Their anger is often vented at close family members or caregivers, forcing the individual to face things will never be the same. They may feel angry that others are starting to be overprotective or treat them as incapable, which can manifest itself in a reluctance to accept assistance or advice on the prevention of further falls.

Stage 3: Bargaining

As individuals transition to the bargaining stage, they may attempt to make deals with themselves or others around them in the hope that they can avoid further falls and that everything can go back to the way it was. “If I do things differently, perhaps I can avoid falling.” This negotiating stage may be expressed in terms such as, “If I just work hard enough, maybe I won’t need help after all,” or “If I exercise more, I won’t fall as I’ll be stronger.”

During this stage the faller may be inclined to try out mobility devices, physical therapy, and medications, but if these measures don’t work and they fall again then they will become disillusioned, potentially sinking into the next stage of grief — that of depression. While hope can be a powerful motivator, bargaining can also mask the fear that “normal” may never return. It is an attempt to regain control in a situation that feels uncontrollable.

Stage 4: Depression

This is often the hardest stage for the person experiencing it as well as for their loved ones witnessing it. It is a period of mourning the loss of independence, of coming to terms with physical limitations, and of feeling isolated, defeated, sad, and helpless. Depression is further complicated by the fact that many older adults will experience depression even without having fallen.

The fear of falling, also known as post-fall syndrome (PFS), can cause fallers to avoid activities they used to enjoy, such as walking, gardening, and socializing. They may feel that their life as they know it is slipping away and begin to mourn their pre-fall life, vocalizing their apathy and lack of purpose as, “What’s the point?”

The grief can run deep: for the body that once cooperated, for the freedom that once felt permanent, and for the identity that now feels uncertain. While mourning their previous life, it is not without irony that depression in itself can lead to a fall.

Stage 5: Acceptance

When an individual is at the point of accepting their situation and the changes that need to be made, they may find some peace in their life. Acceptance doesn’t mean liking the situation, or accepting that falls are going to happen, or they have stopped caring about their risk of falling. It means acknowledging reality and finding new ways to live within it. “Things are different now, but I can still have a good life.”

In this stage, older adults begin to rebuild their confidence and sense of self — often with surprising resilience and creativity. It is a time where older adults may embrace preventative measures such as using mobility aids, engaging in balance exercises, and making changes to their living environment, such as removing rugs, removing clutter, and improving lighting. They may also open up to someone about their feelings.

Reaching the acceptance stage actually gives the faller more control in their life, not less. It is part of redefining what independence means, but it does not mean that independence is lost. They are still concerned about the falls but are accepting the reality of their situation and the fact they are going to need to make changes to maintain their quality of life.

***

It should be noted that not everyone will experience all 5 of the stages of grief. Some may skip some, others may move back and forth between them, along with an uncertain timeline for each of the 5 stages.

Moving Forward With Compassion

The emotional aftermath of a fall is often overlooked in favor of physical healing. But to truly support older adults, we must also see and honor the emotional landscape they’re navigating. Understanding this experience through the eyes of the 5 stages of grief can provide an insight into the thoughts and feelings of the faller, who seeks clarity, empathy, and a path toward healing.

A fall can shatter more than bones—it can fracture a person’s sense of self, confidence, and autonomy. Often the faller will not share with anyone that they have fallen. Their need to maintain their independence despite the fall will place them in the denial stage of the grief model. Whether you’re an older adult yourself, a caregiver, or a loved one, recognizing these stages can make space for honest conversations, patience, and healing.

But it should also be noted that the faller’s spouse may also be moving through the grief model, as they see their own life changing, and their own mortality is more obvious due to the change they see in their partner. However, that spouse needs to move forward with the compassion required to provide an emotionally supportive environment for their loved one as they not only experience the fear of falling again or come to terms with what they perceive as the loss of their independence.

References Kὕbler-Ross E. On Death and Dying. NY, NY: Macmillan, 1969